The Bottom Line
Pros
- Extensive analysis of ECW events by Paul Heyman
- Detailed backgrounds of the key players prior to entering ECW
- The feuds and matches covered are only from the glory days of the promotion
- The final chapter has opinions of several ECW wrestlers in regards to different events
Cons
- Like the DVD, the WWE is portrayed as a hero while WCW is the villain
- Several errors, the worst being the wrong cause of death for Chris Candido
- Some of the pages appear to be word for word transcriptions of other WWE releases
Description
- The book is written by Thom Loverro and features interviews with Paul Heyman and other ECW stars
- The hardcover book is 272 pages
- Eight pages of color photos
- The cover prices is $26
Guide Review - The rise & fall of ECW by Thom Loverro
Unfortunately, there is a lot of revision about the role the WWE and WCW played in the collapse of the company. The worst example of this was the discussion of the wrestlers lost to WCW in 1995 (Benoit, Malenko, & Guerrero). At no point during that tirade against WCW was it mentioned that Shane Douglas was in the WWF. When the Douglas return from the WWF is mentioned, it made it seem that the WWF only took ECW wrestlers when ECW didn't need them anymore. All I know is that the first ECW show I went to was supposed to have Steve Austin in the main event. Before the show started, Paul Heyman addressed the crowd about Austin not being there because he was signed by the WWF and he even offered the crowd a refund.
Outside of this, the book was really fascinating to read. There were many details exposed in this book that none of the other books about ECW mentioned. The editing that I really enjoyed was in regards to the analysis of the matches and booking. All the storylines that are mentioned in the book are the important ones.
Overall Recommendation: Buy this book





